Similarity Check Reports

Similarity Check Reports

Last updated: November 7, 2026Crossref Similarity CheckTurnitin

Through its membership of Crossref, Jurnal Ilmiah Peuradeun (JIP) uses Crossref Similarity Check (iThenticate), together with Turnitin, to highlight text overlap between a submitted manuscript and existing literature. Every manuscript is checked before it is sent to reviewers. When needed, the editorial office sends the similarity report to the authors so that they can see where the overlap occurs.

Screening Threshold

Similarity Threshold. JIP uses the results of Turnitin and Crossref Similarity Check (iThenticate) as a screening threshold. Overall similarity must be below 20%, and similarity with any single source must not exceed 3%. References and correctly marked direct quotations are excluded. A manuscript that exceeds this threshold is returned to the authors for revision before it is processed further, or is rejected if the overlap indicates plagiarism.

The percentage is only an aid. A high percentage is not automatically unacceptable, and a low percentage does not guarantee that a manuscript is free of plagiarism. The editor always examines the report to see the sources of overlap and where it occurs.

Reading a Report

When assessing a similarity report, the editor considers:

  1. The nature of the overlap. Are the similarities fragmentary or in blocks? Are complete sentences or paragraphs copied from previous works?
  2. Where the overlap occurs. Duplication of background ideas in the introduction or of standard method descriptions may be less significant than duplication in the results, discussion, or conclusions.
  3. Data duplication. Reusing data or figures without appropriate citation is almost never acceptable.
  4. Citation. Was the source of the overlapping text cited and discussed?
  5. Authorship of the source. If the source was written by one or more of the same authors, the concern may be redundant publication or text recycling rather than plagiarism. Overlap with the authors' own thesis or dissertation may be acceptable if it is disclosed and cited. JIP does not consider manuscripts that have already been posted publicly as a preprint.
  6. Software limits. The software may overstate similarity, for example by counting properly quoted text, standard terminology, or the reference list.

What Happens Next

Result of the check Action
Within the threshold and the overlap is acceptable The manuscript continues to peer review.
Above the threshold, without signs of plagiarism The manuscript is returned to the authors to rewrite the overlapping sections and add missing citations before review.
Plagiarism or self-plagiarism found The manuscript is rejected, in line with the Policy of Screening for Plagiarism.
Problem found after publication Handled through a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction, in line with Editorial Integrity.

What Authors Should Do

  • Check your own work before submission and cite every source at the point where it is used.
  • When a report is returned to you, rewrite the overlapping passages in your own words, add the missing citations, and mark direct quotations clearly.
  • Explain in your response to the editor what you changed, especially if you believe the overlap is acceptable (for example, a standard method description).
  • Make sure every reference exists and is relevant, in line with Citation Integrity.

If you have any questions about a similarity report, or concerns about plagiarism in an article, please contact info.jip@scadindependent.org.