Editorial Workflow

Editorial Workflow

Last updated: November 6, 2026Double-Blind Peer Review

Jurnal Ilmiah Peuradeun uses Open Journal Systems 3.4.0.9, open-source software for managing and publishing journals that is developed and distributed free of charge by the Public Knowledge Project under the GNU General Public License. The entire editorial workflow is carried out through OJS.

Editorial Authority and Criteria

The editorial workflow gives editors the authority to reject a manuscript because its subject is inappropriate, its quality is insufficient, or its results are incorrect. An editor cannot assign himself or herself as an external reviewer of a manuscript. This ensures a high-quality, fair, and unbiased peer review, because every manuscript must be recommended by two or more external reviewers together with the editor handling the manuscript before it can be accepted.

The journal receives more manuscripts than it can publish. Editors may reject a manuscript without peer review if it is judged not to meet the journal's minimum requirements. All manuscripts must fit the focus, scope, and author guidelines of the journal. To be published in JIP, a manuscript must meet eight general criteria:

  1. The manuscript is original work.
  2. The methodology suits the research topic.
  3. It is novel. Manuscripts that have already been posted publicly as a preprint, or translations of works that have already been published, are not considered.
  4. It contains sound analysis.
  5. It has global impact, that is, it shows how local evidence contributes to global or cross-cultural scholarly debate.
  6. It provides strong evidence for its conclusions.
  7. It is highly important to scholars in its field.
  8. Ideally, it is of interest to researchers in related disciplines.

In general, an acceptable manuscript must offer an understanding that can influence thinking in its field, with a clear reason why the work deserves to be published in JIP.

Workflow Steps

JIP relies on peer review to maintain the quality and validity of the articles it publishes. All manuscripts are reviewed through a rigorous and fair double-blind peer review that ensures the quality of published articles. This statement is based on the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers. Every manuscript goes through the following editorial workflow.

  1. One editor normally handles a manuscript from beginning to end. The editor assesses whether the manuscript fits the focus and scope of the journal, then checks the level of similarity with Crossref Similarity Check (iThenticate) and Turnitin. Manuscripts outside the scope or containing plagiarism, including self-plagiarism, are rejected.
  2. The editor reads each new manuscript within 7–21 working days, which may take longer when the queue is long. A manuscript may be returned before review if it is outside the scope, contains plagiarism, exceeds the word limit, or is not yet ready to be processed further and published.
  3. Manuscripts that are potentially suitable are sent to reviewers. Reviewers are selected and invited by the editor handling the manuscript, under the supervision of the Editor-in-Chief. Reviewers are external experts in the field of the manuscript and are not members of the editorial staff. Licensed tools or OJS features may help suggest potential reviewers, but the choice remains with the editor. Authors may suggest potential reviewers, but these suggestions are only considered and the editor is not obliged to use them. Suggested reviewers should be given with their Full Name, Email, Affiliation, ORCID iD link, Scopus ID link, Google Scholar link, and other details.
  4. Each manuscript is reviewed by at least 2 (two) reviewers through a double-blind system. Each reviewer is asked to complete the review within 4–6 weeks. Overall, including any rounds of revision, the review process may take 2–4 months. If there is a delay, the authors will be told the reason and may withdraw the manuscript if they wish by sending a withdrawal request through the OJS account and by email. Authors may also withdraw a manuscript at any time before the APC is paid (see Editorial Integrity).
  5. Reviewers submit their report and one of the following recommendations to the editor: Accept Submission, Revisions Required, Resubmit for Review, Resubmit Elsewhere, or Decline Submission.
  6. The outcome of the review is sent to the authors through their OJS account, with a notification also sent by email. If revision is needed, the authors are asked to resubmit the manuscript revised according to the reviewers' suggestions, together with a Table of Correction (ToC).
  7. Authors have a maximum of 2 (two) weeks for revision from the date of notification. At the end of the second week, our system sends a first reminder with an extension of 1 (one) week. At the end of the third week, our system sends a second (final) reminder. A manuscript that has not been revised by the end of the fourth week is stopped and archived with the status withdrawn or declined.
  8. Authors of accepted manuscripts receive a Letter of Article Acceptance (LAA). Accepted manuscripts are then sent to the copyeditor to refine language and clarity. Working with the authors, the copyeditor ensures completeness and consistency with the journal's bibliographic and text style, then passes the manuscript to the layout editor, who converts it into PDF or HTML galley files in the journal's publication format.
  9. Before publication, the galley files are sent to the proofreader to be read and checked for writing and formatting errors together with the authors. Typographical and formatting errors are corrected by the layout editor. Finally, the manuscript is sent to the publication editor, who sets the publication schedule and DOI, updates the website, and updates the metadata.

Decisions and Publication Time

The decision to accept, revise, or reject a manuscript is made by the editor on the basis of the reviewers' comments and recommendations. Where necessary, the editor may send the manuscript to another reviewer before deciding. Final approval for publication is given by the Editor-in-Chief together with the Editorial Board, on the recommendation of the Editorial Team. The schedule and order of articles in each issue are set by considering the acceptance date, the geographical distribution of authors, and the theme of the issue. These factors apply to scheduling only, not to accepting or rejecting manuscripts. It usually takes about 6 months to 1 year from submission to publication, and it may take longer depending on the manuscript queue. If there is a delay, the authors will be informed.