Generative AI policies for journals
Generative AI Policies
This policy governs the use of generative artificial intelligence and AI-based technologies ("AI tools") by the authors, reviewers, and editors of Jurnal Ilmiah Peuradeun (JIP). It is based on the COPE position statement Authorship and AI Tools, the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing version 5.0, and DOAJ guidance. JIP reviews this policy regularly in line with developments in best practice.
For Reviewers
- The manuscript under review is a confidential document. Reviewers must not upload the manuscript, any part of its content, or the review report to a generative AI tool, even just to improve the language.
- Reviewers must not use generative AI tools to assess the manuscript or to write the review report. Scholarly assessment requires critical thinking for which only humans can be accountable.
- Reviewers are fully responsible for the content of the review report.
- If a reviewer suspects that the authors used AI without declaring it, the reviewer reports this confidentially to the editor.
For Editors
- During assessment, editors must not upload manuscripts, decision letters, or communications about manuscripts to public generative AI tools. Language polishing after a manuscript is accepted follows the section "Tools Used by the JIP Editorial Office".
- Editors must not use generative AI tools to assess manuscripts or make decisions. Editors are responsible for the editorial process, the final decision, and how it is communicated to the authors.
- If an editor suspects that authors or reviewers have breached this policy, the editor handles it under "Violations" below.
Tools Used by the JIP Editorial Office
The JIP editorial office uses licensed tools that protect the confidentiality of manuscripts to support technical work:
| Tool | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Crossref Similarity Check (iThenticate) and Turnitin | Checking text similarity and detecting possible duplicate submission |
| Open Journal Systems (OJS) features | Managing the manuscript workflow, checking file completeness, and helping to suggest potential reviewers |
| QuillBot and Grammarly | Checking spelling, grammar, and punctuation at the copyediting stage, without AI paraphrasing or rewriting features, and only after the manuscript has been accepted. The manuscript is not uploaded; only selected sentences or passages of text are checked. Suggestions from these tools are reviewed by the copyeditor; the final decision on every change remains with humans, namely the copyeditor and the authors. Not used to assess manuscripts or make decisions. |
These tools only assist. Every editorial decision, including rejection without review, the selection of reviewers, and the acceptance or rejection of manuscripts, is made by an editor. During screening, review, and decision-making, manuscripts are not uploaded to generative AI tools. QuillBot and Grammarly are used only to check spelling, grammar, and punctuation after a manuscript has been accepted; their AI paraphrasing and rewriting features are not used. The manuscript file is not uploaded to these tools; only selected sentences or passages of text are checked, using account settings that do not allow the text to be used to train the tools. Every suggestion from the tools is reviewed by the copyeditor, and the final decision to accept or reject it is always made by a human. The result is checked and approved by the authors at the proofreading stage.
Violations
- Authors who use AI without declaring it or who breach the table above: before publication, the authors are asked to complete the declaration or revise the manuscript, and the manuscript may be rejected; after publication, JIP publishes a correction, or an expression of concern or a retraction if the breach affects the reliability of the content.
- Reviewers who use generative AI in their review: the report is not used, the manuscript is sent to another reviewer, and the reviewer is not invited again.
- Editors who breach this policy: they are removed from handling the manuscript, and their decision is reviewed again by the Editor-in-Chief.
- Cases are handled according to the COPE flowcharts and the Editorial Integrity page.









