Peer Review Process

Peer Review Process

Last updated: November 6, 2026Double-BlindAt least 2 reviewers

Jurnal Ilmiah Peuradeun (JIP) applies a rigorous and fair double-blind review that ensures the quality of the articles it publishes. In this system the identities of both reviewers and authors are kept confidential. This anonymity prevents reviewer bias, for example on the basis of the author's country of origin or controversial previous work. Manuscripts by well-known authors are assessed on their content, not their reputation. This statement is based on the COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.

How Review Works

All manuscripts go through peer review. Manuscripts that pass the editor's initial screening are sent to reviewers. Each manuscript is reviewed by at least 2 (two) reviewers. Each reviewer is asked to complete the review within 4–6 weeks. Overall, including any rounds of revision, the review process may take 2–4 months. If there is a delay, the authors will be told the reason and may withdraw the manuscript if they wish by sending a withdrawal request through the OJS account and by email. Authors may also withdraw a manuscript at any time before the APC is paid (see Editorial Integrity).

Manuscripts accepted with minor or major revisions must be revised according to the reviewers' comments and suggestions. Reviewers submit their report and one of the following recommendations to the editor: Accept Submission, Revisions Required, Resubmit for Review, Resubmit Elsewhere, or Decline Submission.

The decision to accept, revise, or reject a manuscript is made by the editor on the basis of the reviewers' comments and recommendations. Where necessary, the editor may send the manuscript to another reviewer before deciding. Final approval for publication is given by the Editor-in-Chief together with the Editorial Board. The schedule and order of publication take into account the acceptance date, the geographical distribution of authors, and the theme of the issue; these factors apply to scheduling only, not to accepting or rejecting manuscripts. It usually takes about 6 months to 1 year from submission to publication, and it may take longer depending on the manuscript queue. If there is a delay, the authors will be informed.

Peer Review Provisions

Provision JIP policy
Who reviewers are External experts in the field and/or method of the manuscript, who are not members of the JIP editorial staff
Who selects reviewers The editor handling the manuscript, under the supervision of the Editor-in-Chief. Licensed tools or OJS features may help suggest potential reviewers; the choice remains with the editor.
Reviewers suggested by authors Allowed. Suggestions are only considered and the editor is not obliged to use them. Suggested reviewers must not have a conflict of interest with the authors; the editor verifies their identity and expertise. Suggestions should include the full name, email, affiliation, and links to the ORCID iD, Scopus ID, and Google Scholar profile.
Number of reviewers At least 2 (two) per manuscript
Type of review Double-blind: the authors' identities are concealed from the reviewers, and the reviewers' identities are concealed from the authors
Time 4–6 weeks per reviewer; 2–4 months for the whole process, including revision
Confidentiality Manuscripts and review reports are confidential. Reviewers must not contact authors directly.
Help from others Reviewers must not involve anyone else without the editor's permission; the names of anyone who helped are reported to the editor.
Use of AI by reviewers Reviewers must not upload manuscripts or review reports to generative AI tools or use them to prepare their assessment (see GenAI Policies).
Supplementary material Supplementary material uploaded by the authors is also sent to the reviewers and reviewed. It must be anonymised, like the manuscript.
Review reports Not signed and not published with the article; editors' comments and authors' responses are not published either.
Exceptions If an article was reviewed in a way that differs from this policy, the article states how it was reviewed.
Dates on the article Each article shows the dates on which it was Received, Revised, Accepted, and Published.
Editor training All editors who decide on manuscripts receive training on peer review procedures, reviewer selection, conflicts of interest, the scope of review, handling inappropriate reviewer comments, and communicating revision requests.
Questions Authors and reviewers can contact the editor at info.jip@scadindependent.org.

Editing of Review Reports

Review reports must be courteous, objective, and focused on the scholarly content of the manuscript. Editors may edit, or not pass on to the authors, any part of a report that:

  • contains rude or demeaning language, or personal attacks;
  • reveals the identity of the reviewer or the authors;
  • contains irrelevant or coercive requests for citations;
  • contains confidential information or unfounded accusations.

Editors do not change the reviewer's scholarly assessment or recommendation. If a report is edited, the reviewer is informed. If a report cannot be used, the editor may seek the opinion of another reviewer.