Publication Ethics
Publication Ethics
Jurnal Ilmiah Peuradeun (JIP), the Indonesian Journal of the Social Sciences, is an online, peer-reviewed, open-access journal. Its main objective is to disseminate scientific knowledge and generate debate in an interdisciplinary context that links the different areas of the social sciences. This statement sets out the ethical behaviour expected of all parties involved in publishing an article in JIP, namely the authors, the editors, the reviewers, and the publisher (SCAD Independent), based on the COPE Code of Conduct and Best Practice Guidelines for Journal Editors and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing.
Ethical Guideline for Journal Publication
The publication of an article in a peer-reviewed Jurnal Ilmiah Peuradeun is an essential building block in the development of a coherent and respected network of knowledge. It is a direct reflection of the quality of the work of the authors and the institutions that support them. Peer-reviewed articles support and embody the scientific method. It is therefore important to agree upon standards of expected ethical behavior for all parties involved in the act of publishing: the author, the journal editor, the peer reviewer, the publisher, and the society.
SCAD Independent as the publisher of this journal takes its duties of guardianship over all stages of publishing extremely seriously and we recognize our ethical and other responsibilities. We are committed to ensuring that publication charges, advertising, reprints, and any other commercial revenue have no impact or influence on editorial decisions. In addition, the SCAD Independent and Editorial Board will assist in communications with other journals and/or publishers where such collaboration is useful and necessary.
Allegations of Research Misconduct
Research misconduct means fabrication, falsification, citation manipulation, or plagiarism in producing, performing, or reviewing research and writing the article by authors, or in reporting research results. When authors are found to have been involved with research misconduct or other serious irregularities involving articles that have been published in scientific journals, editors have a responsibility to ensure the accuracy and integrity of the scientific record.
In cases of suspected misconduct, the editors and editorial board will use the best practices of COPE to assist them to resolve the complaint and address the misconduct fairly. This will include an investigation of the allegation by the editors. A submitted manuscript that is found to contain such misconduct will be rejected. In cases where a published paper is found to contain such misconduct, a retraction can be published and will be linked to the original article.
The first step involves determining the validity of the allegation and an assessment of whether the allegation is consistent with the definition of research misconduct. This initial step also involves determining whether the individuals alleging misconduct have relevant conflicts of interest.
If scientific misconduct or the presence of other substantial research irregularities is a possibility, the allegations are shared with the corresponding author, who, on behalf of all of the coauthors, is requested to provide a detailed response. After the response is received and evaluated, additional review and involvement of experts (such as statistical reviewers) may be obtained. For cases in which it is unlikely that misconduct has occurred, clarifications, additional analyses, or both, published as letters to the editor and often including a correction notice and correction to the published article are sufficient.
We expect institutions to conduct a thorough and appropriate investigation into allegations of scientific misconduct. Ultimately, authors, journals, and institutions have an important obligation to ensure the accuracy of the scientific record. By responding appropriately to concerns about scientific misconduct and taking necessary actions based on the evaluation of these concerns, such as corrections, retractions with replacement, and retractions, this journal, in collaboration with SCAD Independent as the publisher, will continue to fulfill the responsibilities of ensuring the validity and integrity of the scientific record.
Plagiarism
Authors must not use the words, figures, data, or ideas of others without attribution. All sources must be cited at the point they are used, and reuse of wording must be limited and be attributed or quoted in the text.
Similarity Threshold. JIP uses the results of Turnitin and Crossref Similarity Check (iThenticate) as a screening threshold. Overall similarity must be below 20%, and similarity with any single source must not exceed 3%. References and correctly marked direct quotations are excluded. A manuscript that exceeds this threshold is returned to the authors for revision before it is processed further, or is rejected if the overlap indicates plagiarism. Authors can see our Similarity Check page for more information on how to interpret these reports.
The percentage is only an aid. The editor still assesses the nature, location, and extent of the overlap:
- a manuscript with a low percentage may still be rejected if it is shown to contain plagiarism, for example by copying a whole section or an idea without attribution;
- overlap arising from standard terminology, standard descriptions of methods, or legitimate quotations is not automatically regarded as plagiarism.
JIP regards the following as violations:
- Plagiarism: copying the words or ideas of others without acknowledgment.
- Self-plagiarism: reusing one's own work without disclosure, including duplicate or overlapping publication (redundant/overlapping publication) and text recycling.
- Submitting a manuscript that is already available as a public preprint, or a translation of a work that has already been published. JIP does not consider such manuscripts.
Manuscripts found to contain such violations will be rejected, and the authors may incur sanctions. Published articles may be corrected or retracted.
Citation Integrity
Every reference in a manuscript must exist, be relevant to the content of the manuscript, and represent the content of the cited work accurately. Authors must check every reference and its DOI, including references found or formatted with the help of AI tools or reference management software.
Citation manipulation is the inclusion of references that do not contribute to the scholarly content of the manuscript and serve only to increase the citations of an author, a colleague, or a particular journal. JIP regards the following as violations:
- fictitious or unverifiable references;
- irrelevant or excessive citations (citation stacking);
- agreements to cite one another between authors or between journals (citation cartels);
- citations demanded by reviewers or editors (coercive citation).
Self-citation limit. Citations to the authors' own work may make up no more than 10% of all references, unless this is genuinely necessary and explained, for example in a very narrow field of study.
Citations to JIP. Editors and reviewers may suggest relevant references to improve a manuscript, but must not require citations to their own work or to JIP articles. Adding citations is never a condition of acceptance, and authors should not feel pressured to cite sources that are not relevant.
Checks by the editorial office. The editorial office checks references and DOIs at initial screening and at copyediting. For sources that are hard to access, such as historical sources, sources in other languages, or sources whose DOI cannot be opened from outside the author's country, authors may be asked to provide a copy. Citations added after peer review are also checked.
Handling. The editor assesses citation problems by their nature, location, type, and scale.
- Minor errors are dealt with by revision, or by a correction if the article has already been published.
- A significant number of fictitious references, or citation manipulation, may lead to rejection of the manuscript or, if the article has already been published, to an expression of concern or a retraction, in accordance with the Editorial Integrity procedures.
- Patterns that recur across several manuscripts or articles are handled together with the publisher.
Publication Decisions
The editors of JIP are responsible for deciding which of the manuscripts submitted to the journal are published. Decisions are based solely on scholarly merit, validity, and the importance of the work to researchers and readers. Decisions must not be influenced by the origin of the manuscript, or by the nationality, ethnicity, political beliefs, race, or religion of the authors, by external pressure, or by the authors' ability to pay publication charges. The editors may be guided by the policies of the editorial board and constrained by such legal requirements as shall then be in force regarding libel, copyright infringement, and plagiarism, and may confer with other editors or reviewers. JIP does not guarantee acceptance of any submitted manuscript.
Duties of Editors
Responsibilities: The editor of a journal holds a vital position taking important editorial decisions on all peer-reviewed submitted for publication.
Fair Play: An editor at any time evaluate manuscripts for their intellectual content without regard to race, gender, sexual orientation, religious belief, ethnic origin, citizenship, or political philosophy of the authors. The editor should evaluate manuscripts objectively based on their academic merit free of any commercial or self-interests.
Confidentiality: The editor and any editorial staff must not disclose any information about a submitted manuscript to anyone other than the corresponding author, reviewers, potential reviewers, other editorial advisers, and the publisher, as appropriate.
Disclosure and Conflict of Interest: Unpublished materials disclosed in a submitted manuscript must not be used in an editor's own research without the express written consent of the author. An editor who has a conflict of interest with a manuscript must withdraw from handling it and from any decision on it (see Conflicts of Interest).
Transparency Academic: The editor should maintain the transparency of the academic research & record, preclude professional needs from cooperating with ethical standards, and always be willing to publish retractions, rectifications, and erratums when required.
Rectitude: Promoting research rectitude must be preserved. If at any stage the publisher suspects any kind of misconduct in research, it should be investigated promptly in detail with suitable authority; and if any suspicious act of misconduct is observed in the peer review, it should be resolved with diligence.
Use of AI: Editors do not upload manuscripts or decision letters to public generative AI tools and do not use such tools to assess manuscripts or make decisions (see GenAI Policies).
Duties of Reviewers
Contribution to Editorial Decisions: Peer review assists the editor in making editorial decisions and through the editorial communications with the author may also assist the author in improving the paper.
Promptness: Any selected referee who feels unqualified to review the research reported in a manuscript or knows that its prompt review will be impossible should notify the editor and excuse himself from the review process.
Confidentiality: Any manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents. They must not be shown to or discussed with others except as authorized by the editor. Since peer review is confidential, the reviewer also must not share information about the review with anyone without permission from the editors. In line with the JIP GenAI Policies, reviewers must not upload manuscripts or review reports to generative AI tools.
Citations: Reviewers should not suggest citations to the reviewer’s (or their associates’) work unless the suggested citations are for genuine scientific reasons and not with the intention of increasing the reviewer’s citation count or enhancing the visibility of their work (or that of their associates). Editors may remove inappropriate citations from reviewer comments (see Citation Integrity).
Standards of Objectivity: Reviews should be conducted objectively, providing a detailed, critically, constructive, and unbiased evaluation in a timely manner of the scientific content of the work. Referees should express their views clearly with supporting arguments.
Acknowledgment of Sources: Reviewers should identify the relevant published work that has not been cited by the authors. Any statement that an observation, derivation, or argument had been previously reported should be accompanied by the relevant citation. A reviewer should also call to the editor's attention any substantial similarity or overlap between the manuscript under consideration and any other published paper of which they have personal knowledge, and also notified of the journal editor of any ethical concerns in their evaluation of submitted manuscripts; such as any violation of ethical treatment of animal or human subjects.
Disclosure and Conflict of Interest: Privileged information or ideas obtained through peer review must be kept confidential and not used for personal advantage. Reviewers should not consider manuscripts in which they have conflicts of interest resulting from competitive, collaborative, or other relationships or connections with any of the authors, companies, or institutions connected to the papers. Reviewers notify the journal editor about any financial or personal conflict of interest and decline to review the manuscript when a possibility of such a conflict exists (see Conflicts of Interest).
Research Ethics
- Research involving human participants must be approved by a research ethics committee. Where no ethics committee is available, the research must follow the Declaration of Helsinki, and the authors explain this.
- Authors must obtain informed consent from participants and protect the confidentiality of personal data.
- If participants can be identified from the text, photographs, or data, the authors must obtain written consent for publication and state this in the article.
- Research that is exempt from ethical review must be accompanied by proof of the exemption, for example a letter from the ethics committee.
- Research involving chemicals, procedures, or equipment with unusual hazards must state those hazards clearly.
- The ethics statement (Ethics statement) is placed at the end of the Method section.
- If the research uses confidential or business data, the authors explain how the data are protected.
Conflicts of Interest
Definition. A conflict of interest is an interest that influences, or could reasonably be perceived to influence, the conduct and reporting of research, its review, decision-making, or publication in a full and objective way. It includes:
- financial: funding, honoraria, shareholding, patents, consultancy;
- personal: family relationships, friendship, or hostility;
- political or religious: beliefs or memberships directly related to the content of the manuscript;
- academic or professional: competition, a supervisor–student relationship, the same institution;
- institutional or ownership: the interests of an institution, a sponsor, or the publisher.
Applies to authors, reviewers, editors, the journal, and the publisher.
| Party | When | To whom and how |
|---|---|---|
| Authors | At submission, and whenever a conflict arises during the process | Declaration of Competing Interests in the manuscript and in the OJS field; if there is none: "The authors declare no competing interests." |
| Reviewers | When accepting the invitation, and whenever a conflict arises | Competing interests field in OJS or email to the editor; reviewers decline the invitation if the conflict is significant |
| Editors | When assigned to handle a manuscript | To the Editor-in-Chief; the manuscript is reassigned to another editor |
| Editor-in-Chief | When assigned, or when giving final approval | To the Editorial Board; the decision is made by a board member without a conflict |
| Journal and publisher | Where there is an interest in a particular manuscript | Declared and handled under Editorial Integrity |
Duty to withdraw. Editors and reviewers who have a significant conflict of interest with a manuscript withdraw from reviewing it and, in the case of editors, from any decision on it.
Manuscripts by editors or editorial board members. A manuscript written by an editor or editorial board member of JIP is handled by another editor without a conflict, through the same double-blind peer review, and its author has no access to the handling of the manuscript.
Limits and transparency for manuscripts by editors. To keep the journal's content balanced, JIP sets the following:
- editors and editorial board members are subject to the Author Publication Frequency provisions in the Editorial Policies, namely one article per author per issue and an interval of three issues;
- articles that include an editor or editorial board member among their authors make up no more than 7% of all articles in a single issue;
- manuscripts by the Editor-in-Chief are handled by a designated member of the Editorial Board who has no conflict;
- such articles carry a statement that one of the authors is an editor or editorial board member of JIP and that the manuscript was handled independently by another editor through double-blind peer review.
If a conflict is not declared:
- Before publication: the authors are asked to complete the declaration; the manuscript may be rejected if the conflict affected the assessment.
- After publication: JIP publishes a correction, or an expression of concern or a retraction if the conflict affects the interpretation or conclusions.
- Reviewers or editors who did not declare a conflict are removed from handling the manuscript, and their report or decision is reviewed again.
- Where necessary, JIP informs the institution concerned, following the COPE flowcharts.
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
JIP is committed to diversity, equity, accessibility, and inclusion in its governance and content. JIP builds an editorial board and a pool of reviewers that are diverse in geography and expertise, assesses manuscripts without discriminating on the basis of the authors' background, and works to keep its website and articles easy to access.
Duties of the Publisher
Guardianship of the scholarly record
SCAD Independent supports and nurtures the scholarly communication process and is responsible for ensuring that best practice is followed in each of its publications. SCAD Independent safeguards the integrity of the scholarly record that it publishes.
SCAD Independent is adopting policies and procedures to support editors, reviewers and authors in performing their ethical duties under guidelines. We work with other publishers and industry associations to set standards for best practices on ethical matters, errors and retractions.
Handling of Unethical Publishing Behavior
In cases of alleged or proven scientific misconduct, fraudulent publication, or plagiarism, the publisher, in close collaboration with the editors, will take all appropriate measures to clarify the situation and amend the article in question. This includes the prompt publication of an erratum, clarification, or in the most severe case, the retraction of the affected work. The publisher, together with the editors, shall take reasonable steps to identify and prevent the publication of papers where research misconduct has occurred and under no circumstances encourage such misconduct or knowingly allow such misconduct to take place.
Access to Journal Content
SCAD Independent ensures the permanent availability of the journal's content through its own digital archive and through LOCKSS and the PKP Preservation Network; JIP articles are also deposited in Garuda, Sinta, and the SCAD Independent repository.
Safeguard editorial independence
We are committed to ensuring that the potential for advertising, reprint or other commercial revenue has no impact or influence on editorial decisions. In addition, editorial staff are forbidden to use information acquired through their work for personal gain. See Editorial Integrity.
Provide editors with technical, procedural & legal support
We support editors in communications with other journals and/or publishers where this is useful to editors and are prepared to provide specialized legal review and counsel if necessary.
Educate researchers on publishing ethics
We also provide extensive education and advice on publishing ethics standards, particularly for early career researchers.









